I give this a qualified 5 stars because it does what it is advertised to do. It holds four, up to a 5 inch barrel, semi auto pistols perfectly and their magazines securely. There is not much room for anything else, so don't think of this as a replacement for your range bag. You can pull the magazine insert out to make more room for whatever, but there is still not a ton of room for much. Will not work with anything longer than a 5 inch barrel.It is lightweight, but seems to be pretty solid. Not sure I would recommend subjecting it to heavy abuse though. For a trip to the range with multiple guns, it works very well. I shoot some action pistol competitions during some wet weather, and it has worked well keeping stuff dry and secure. Could use a handle, as mentioned in another review, but the price is attractive for you get.Is this a must have? I'm glad I have it and use it often, but do I really need it? Yes and no. Well made and affordable. If you have the money and need something like this, get it.