I read the other two reviews before buying this and I followed along with the good review and am glad I did. As they stated this is a good pouch and it holds 12 shells within with five on the front panel. Other cases like this will run you almost twice as much, and have totally seperate components (I know because I have bought both) and you get the same results as here. I have purchased a great many items off of Amazon at this point and have rarely been disappointed by what I received. I honestly cannot understand any gripe about this pouch, and like other products I have bought am beginning to wonder if a lot of said griping isnt the competition to this manufacturer? To write a review and say it "sucks" or it's "horrible" to me is an utter waste of time, when no explanation of one's troubles are not outlined. Maybe said buyer got a pouch etc with a bad stitch job? If so thats what Amazon customer service is for and having had to use it on a mis-sized pair of gloves in one instance and a pouch with a broken snap, all I can say is that a great many other companies could follow their example. In any case, this pouch does NOT "suck" and does the job nicely. It matched the information provided and holds seventeen shot gun shells without a problem and they do not slip from the panel or fall out of the internal pouch compartment. So... it does exactly what its supposed to do. This pouch attaches very well to a MOLLE system and has good snaps. You get three pal straps to boot, providing a good tight bond. In my case, it's mounted on a dual rifle pouch which had the MOLLE webbing available and provided the fit and "finish" which I like personally. (I like to have closed flap pouches on top of my vest system and dont like to have MOLLE straps showing at all). Were I to need another shotgun pouch I would definitely buy this one again.